Last updated 3/9/2024
| Round 1 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | Eury Perez |
| 2 | Shenandoah | Jordan Walker |
| 3 | Las Vegas | Evan Carter |
| 4 | Texas | Elly De La Cruz |
| 5 | San Francisco | Tanner Bibee |
| 6 | Oakland | Yainer Diaz |
| 7 | Rock Creek from La Grange | Anthony Volpe |
| 8 | Windy City | Nolan Jones |
| 9 | Rock Creek from Hellgate | Junior Caminero |
| 10 | Prescott | Matt McLain |
| 11 | Las Vegas from Cincinnati | Ezequiel Duran |
| 12 | Springfield | James Outman |
| 13 | Rock Creek | Zack Gelof |
| Round 2 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | Grayson Rodriguez |
| 2 | Shenandoah | Gavin Williams |
| 3 | Las Vegas | Bobby Miller |
| 4 | Texas | Yennier Cano |
| 5 | San Francisco | Kodai Senga |
| 6 | Oakland | Masataka Yoshida |
| 7 | Rock Creek from La Grange | Edouard Julien |
| 8 | Windy City | Christian Encarnacion |
| 9 | Rock Creek from Hellgate | Patrick Bailey |
| 10 | Prescott | Cristopher Sanchez |
| 11 | Las Vegas from Cincinnati | Cole Ragans |
| 12 | Springfield | Chas McCormick |
| 13 | Rock Creek | Charlie Morton |
| Round 3 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | Noelvi Marte |
| 2 | Shenandoah | Jack Suwinski |
| 3 | Las Vegas | no pick |
| 4 | Texas | Nolan Schanuel |
| 5 | San Francisco | Adbert Alzolay |
| 6 | Oakland | Logan Allen |
| 7 | Rock Creek from La Grange | Justin Topa |
| 8 | Windy City | Pete Crow-Armstrong |
| 9 | La Grange from Hellgate | Josiah Gray |
| 10 | Prescott | Tyler Holton |
| 11 | Springfield | Shawn Armstrong |
| 12 | La Grange from Rock Creek | Andrew Abbott |
| Round 4 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | Jasson Dominguez |
| 2 | Shenandoah | Teoscar Hernandez |
| 3 | Las Vegas | Bryce Miller |
| 4 | Texas | Tom Cosgrove |
| 5 | San Francisco | Matt Strahm |
| 6 | Oakland | Josh Winckowski |
| 7 | La Grange | Matt Manning |
| 8 | Windy City | Trevor Story |
| 9 | Rock Creek from Hellgate | Gregory Santos |
| 10 | Prescott | Javier Assad |
| 11 | Springfield | Jose Trevino |
| 12 | La Grange from Rock Creek | Andrew Nardi |
| Round 5 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | Raisel Iglesias |
| 2 | Shenandoah | Craig Kimbrel |
| 3 | Las Vegas | Jordan Hicks |
| 4 | Texas | Kutter Crawford |
| 5 | San Francisco | Kevin Ginkel |
| 6 | Oakland | Caleb Ferguson |
| 7 | La Grange | Yasmani Grandal |
| 8 | Windy City | Ryan O’Hearn |
| 9 | Hellgate | Nick Martinez |
| 10 | Prescott | Blake Sabol |
| 11 | Las Vegas from Cincinnati | Esteury Ruiz |
| 12 | Springfield | Donovan Solano |
| 13 | La Grange from Rock Creek | Colin Poche |
| Round 6 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | Adam Duvall |
| 2 | Shenandoah | Matt Moore |
| 3 | Las Vegas | Bryan Woo |
| 4 | Texas | Will Benson |
| 5 | San Francisco | Jeff Hoffman |
| 6 | Oakland | Kevin Kelly |
| 7 | La Grange | Kyle Hendricks |
| 8 | Windy City | Drew Rasmussen |
| 9 | Hellgate | Ian Gibaut |
| 10 | Prescott | Orlando Arcia |
| 11 | Springfield | Cristian Javier |
| 12 | Hellgate from Rock Creek | Emilio Pagan |
| Round 7 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | Kyle Harrison |
| 2 | Shenandoah | Adam Ottavino |
| 3 | Las Vegas | no pick |
| 4 | Texas | Connor Wong |
| 5 | San Francisco | Ryan Walker |
| 6 | Oakland | Zach Neto |
| 7 | La Grange | Will Brennan |
| 8 | Windy City | Trevor Rogers |
| 9 | Hellgate | Brent Suter |
| 10 | Prescott | Luis V. Garcia |
| 11 | Springfield | Zach McKinstry |
| 12 | Rock Creek | Ian Hamilton |
| Round 8 | ||
| 1 | Hutchinson | Daniel Coulombe |
| 2 | Shenandoah | pass |
| 3 | Las Vegas | no pick |
| 4 | Texas | Carlos Santana |
| 5 | San Francisco | Danny Jansen |
| 6 | Oakland | Jeff McNeil |
| 7 | Hellgate from La Grange | Brendan Donovan |
| 8 | Windy City | Enrique Hernandez |
| 9 | Rock Creek from Hellgate | Jordan Westburg |
| 10 | Prescott | J.P. France |
| 11 | Springfield | Chris Taylor |
| 12 | Hellgate from Rock Creek | Shelby Miller |